Billy Joel's Greatest Hits are a collection released in 2 sets, the first released in 1985 contained the first 2 discs, and the second was released in 1997. All songs but the last three, To Make You Feel My Love, Hey Girl and Light as the Breeze, were written by Billy Joel. You're Only Human (Second Wind) and The Night is Still Young are only available on Disc 2, and To Make You Feel My Love only appears on Disc 3. The other songs go mostly in order of when they were released.

Disc: 1

• 1. Piano Man
• 2. Captain Jack
• 3. Entertainer
• 4. Say Goodbye to Hollywood
• 5. New York State of Mind
• 6. Stranger
• 7. Scenes from an Italian Restaurant
• 8. Just the Way You Are
• 9. Movin' Out (Anthony's Song)
• 10. Only the Good Die Young
• 11. She's Always a Woman

Disc: 2

• 1. My Life
• 2. Big Shot
• 3. You May Be Right
• 4. It's Still Rock and Roll to Me
• 5. Don't Ask Me Why
• 6. She's Got a Way
• 7. Pressure
• 8. Allentown
• 9. Goodnight Saigon
• 10. Tell Her About It
• 11. Uptown Girl
• 12. The Longest Time
• 13. You're Only Human (Second Wind)
• 14. The Night is Still Young

Disc: 3

• 1. Keeping the Faith
• 2. An Innocent Man
• 3. A Matter of Trust
• 4. Baby Grand
• 5. This is the Time
• 6. Leningrad
• 7. We Didn't Start the Fire
• 8. I Go to Extremes
• 9. And So It Goes
• 10. The Downeaster 'Alexa'
• 11. Shameless
• 12. All About Soul
• 13. Lullabye (Goodnight, My Angel)
• 14. River of Dreams
• 15. To Make You Feel My Life
• 16. Hey Girl
• 17. Light as the Breeze